Warning: include(/var/www/vhosts/footballcritic.com/httpdocs/includes/languages/lang.fr.php): failed to open stream: No such file or directory in /var/www/vhosts/footballcritic.com/httpdocs/index.php on line 92

Warning: include(/var/www/vhosts/footballcritic.com/httpdocs/includes/languages/lang.fr.php): failed to open stream: No such file or directory in /var/www/vhosts/footballcritic.com/httpdocs/index.php on line 92

Warning: include(): Failed opening '/var/www/vhosts/footballcritic.com/httpdocs/includes/languages/lang.fr.php' for inclusion (include_path='.:/usr/share/php') in /var/www/vhosts/footballcritic.com/httpdocs/index.php on line 92
Does home advantage still matter with no fans in stadiums?
Fans

Does home advantage still matter with no fans in stadiums?

A major advantage is having your own fans cheering you on, but how does having empty stands impact on-pitch results?

 
8:00am on Wednesday 16th September 2020
By
Martin Macdonald

When elite leagues around Europe returned after lockdown, having no supporters in attendance was a much-debated issue in terms of the relative impact on home and away results.

Having fans cheering you on for 90 minutes versus the empty shells that games are currently being competed in has been viewed as a potential leveller.

But has it played out like this? CIES Observatory have produced some figures.

READ MORE:

Lampard: Chelsea have aspirations of competing with Liverpool

Barcelona agree fee with Lyon for Memphis

Bellingham becomes BVB's youngest ever goalscorer with debut strike

Odegaard excluded from first Madrid squad of the season

Home Advantage Post-Lockdown

The answer is that home advantage is definitely not defunct, but not quite as effective as it was.

CIES looked at how home teams performed at their own stadium in the years preceding lockdown compared to the matches played behind closed doors.

Looking at 63 leagues worldwide, they discovered that between January 2015 and March 2020, 44.3% of fixtures were won by the home side.

When looking at the prospect of an empty stadium, one hypothesis could have been that this figure would become lower and that did happen, but only just, as after lockdown 42.2% of matches were won by the home side. This figure did, however, fluctuate among the respective leagues.

The leagues with the biggest drop in home wins were the Greek Super League, the Austrian Bundesliga, and then the German Bundesliga. These competitions witnessed pretty significant % swings in favour of the away sides during that period, though the size of the sample must be taken into account.

Top 10 leagues with biggest % drop of home wins

LEAGUE% CHANGE IN HOME WINS
Super League 1 (Greece)-15.1%
Austrian Bundesliga (Austria)-15%
German Bundesliga (Germany)-14.1%
V.League 1(Vietnam)-11.6%
K League 2 (S.Korea)-10.7%
Serie B (Brazil)-9.3%
Allsvenskan (Sweden)-9.1%
Chinese Super League (China)-9%
Russian Premier League (Russia)-8.9%
1.SNL (Slovenia)-8.9%

Latest news

Serie A

When Zlatan and Milan ended Inter's stranglehold - Serie A in 2010/11

Zlatan Ibrahimovic returned to Italian football after an ill-fated spell at Barcelona, and picked up where he left off in Serie A

  • 7 hours
Serie A

Mourinho leads Inter to historic treble - Serie A in 2009/10

Serie A 2009-10: Jose Mourinho leads Inter to historic treble by winning Serie A, the Italian Cup, and the Champions League.

  • 8 hours
Bundesliga

Van Gaal guides Bayern Munich back to the top - the 2009/10 Bundesliga

Bundesliga 2009-10: Louis van Gaal guides Bayern Munich back to the top, with Schalke finishing in second place.

  • 9 hours
La Liga

Mourinho’s Madrid reach 100 points - La Liga in 2011/12

La Liga 2011-12: Jose Mourinho finally gets the better of Pep Guardiola and Barcelona in Spain as Real Madrid reach 100 points.

  • 10 hours
La Liga

Barca edge Madrid in a season of all-out war - La Liga in 2010/11

Jose Mourinho returned to Spain to try and bring down former employers Barcelona and Pep Guardiola

  • 11 hours
Premier League

Manchester United hold off Chelsea in a race down to the wire - the 2007/08 Premier League

Premier League 2007-08 Manchester United hold off Chelsea in a race down to the wire as Cristiano Ronaldo's stardom went stratospheric.

  • 12 hours